Luminar 3 – With Libraries. First looks

Luminar 3 With Libraries was released recently and I’ve been playing with it for a while. Here’s my first impressions:

The Good

  • A reasonable image browser with a unique layout
  • It keeps itself up to date after you have told it the folder(s) where your images are
  • The RAW conversion is high quality, although it is not the best
  • The interface is easy to use
  • Price – currently £47.

The Bad

  • The image browser is not really configurable
  • The browser is slow, often painfully so
  • It doesn’t show any information about the image – not even the name or file type
  • The image browser treats RAW+JPEG as two separate files and doesn’t indicate which one is being displayed
  • Minimal EXIF/IPTC information displayed and only in the Edit screen
  • IPTC cannot be edited
  • External Applications cannot be launched from the Browser
  • Folders added to the browser after the initial import appear at the bottom of the browser tree

To be honest, I was expecting more from Luminar. This update has been a long, long time coming and it offers little more than a basic browser. I have experience with both using and writing Digital Asset Management software. I wrote PFS Manager (which received an 87% rating in Amateur Photographer magazine) and PFS Image Darkroom. I didn’t have a team of developers. It was just me. And my software was faster and had more features.

The Browser

Here is a screen shot of Luminar’s browser and also Photo Ninja’s and Exposure X4’s:

Luminar's Browser Luminar’s Browser
Photo Ninja's Browser Photo Ninja’s Browser
Exposure X4's browser Exposure X4’s browser

Photo Ninja’s browser is lightening fast and Exposure 3’s browser is no slouch either.

Conclusion

Luminar is a very good RAW processor, but it is not the best in class. I would rank Photo Ninja as better, followed by DXO Photo Lab 2. Luminar’s browser is nowhere near as good as Exposure X4’s and Photo Ninja’s is also better.

Hopefully Skylum will enhance the browser over the coming months. Their published roadmap  addresses some of its shortcomings. At the moment it is worth the price, but only as an investment for the future. But this is a highly competitive market and to compete you have to offer something compelling…

Advertisements

1 thought on “Luminar 3 – With Libraries. First looks”

  1. Great short review, thank you ! Just reading the cons is enough for me – a major disappointment on my side, since i was being prepped for a little DAM revolution coming with Luminar 3.. I would also add the lack of local search – if such is absent – to the cons list. How could one leave this out when we talk about DAM / file management is beyond me. And this search should be able to search the exif, eg ISO, aperture, etc – a separate item in the cons list ..

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Recommended Photo Software

Image Resizing

The best image resize program is Topaz A.I.Gigapixel

Image sharpening & noise reduction

Topaz A.I.Sharpen can not only sharpen images but correct slightly out of focus and blurred images.

Topaz A.I.Clear both sharpens and removes noise. It is the best noise reduction program around.

Photoshop and Lightroom Alternatives

Exposure X4 is the best alternative to Lightroom as far as image browsing and management goes. It is also a decent RAW converter and image editor.

Affinity Photo is the complete Photoshop replacement.

RAW Development

Skylum Luminar is a full featured RAW converter with a basic image browser. Its shadow recovery is the best in the business.

Photolemur is an automatic RAW converter, based on Luminar. Its results are very decent with facial detection and enhancement.

Photo Ninja is a purists RAW converter. It is not as fully featured as the others but it produces some of the best results, especially if you are prepared to build camera profiles.